diff --git a/src/components/ModerationLabelPref/PreferenceButton.tsx b/src/components/ModerationLabelPref/PreferenceButton.tsx
deleted file mode 100644
index 199b61ed7c..0000000000
--- a/src/components/ModerationLabelPref/PreferenceButton.tsx
+++ /dev/null
@@ -1,133 +0,0 @@
-import React from 'react'
-import {Pressable} from 'react-native'
-import {useLingui} from '@lingui/react'
-import {msg, Trans} from '@lingui/macro'
-import {InterprettedLabelValueDefinition, LabelPreference} from '@atproto/api'
-
-import {
-  useLabelBehaviorDescription,
-  useLabelLongBehaviorDescription,
-} from '#/lib/moderation/useLabelBehaviorDescription'
-
-import {useTheme, atoms as a} from '#/alf'
-import * as Dialog from '#/components/Dialog'
-import {Text} from '#/components/Typography'
-import {Button, ButtonText, ButtonIcon} from '#/components/Button'
-import {ArrowTriangleBottom_Stroke2_Corner1_Rounded as ArrowTriangleBottom} from '../icons/ArrowTriangle'
-import {Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as Check} from '../icons/Check'
-
-export function PreferenceButton({
-  name,
-  pref,
-  labelValueDefinition,
-  onSelectPref,
-}: {
-  name: string
-  pref: LabelPreference
-  labelValueDefinition: InterprettedLabelValueDefinition
-  onSelectPref: (pref: LabelPreference) => void
-}) {
-  const {_} = useLingui()
-  const t = useTheme()
-  const control = Dialog.useDialogControl()
-
-  const settingDesc = useLabelBehaviorDescription(labelValueDefinition, pref)
-  const hideLabel = useLabelLongBehaviorDescription(
-    labelValueDefinition,
-    'hide',
-  )
-  const warnLabel = useLabelLongBehaviorDescription(
-    labelValueDefinition,
-    'warn',
-  )
-  const ignoreLabel = useLabelLongBehaviorDescription(
-    labelValueDefinition,
-    'ignore',
-  )
-  const canWarn = !(
-    labelValueDefinition.blurs === 'none' &&
-    labelValueDefinition.severity === 'none'
-  )
-
-  return (
-    <>
-      <Pressable
-        onPress={() => control.open()}
-        accessibilityLabel={settingDesc}
-        accessibilityHint=""
-        style={[
-          a.flex_row,
-          a.align_center,
-          a.justify_end,
-          a.gap_xs,
-          a.py_xs,
-          a.rounded_2xs,
-        ]}>
-        <Text style={[{color: t.palette.primary_500}, a.font_semibold]}>
-          {settingDesc}
-        </Text>
-        <ArrowTriangleBottom width={8} fill={t.palette.primary_500} />
-      </Pressable>
-
-      <Dialog.Outer control={control}>
-        <Dialog.Handle />
-
-        <Dialog.Inner
-          label={_(msg`Settings: ${labelValueDefinition.identifier}`)}
-          style={[a.gap_sm]}>
-          <Text style={[a.text_2xl, a.font_bold, a.pb_xs, t.atoms.text]}>
-            {name}
-          </Text>
-          <Text style={[a.text_md, a.pb_sm, t.atoms.text_contrast_medium]}>
-            <Trans>Choose how this label should be handled.</Trans>
-          </Text>
-
-          <Button
-            label={hideLabel}
-            size="large"
-            variant="solid"
-            color={pref === 'hide' ? 'primary' : 'secondary'}
-            onPress={() => {
-              onSelectPref('hide')
-              control.close()
-            }}>
-            <ButtonText style={[a.flex_1, a.text_left]}>{hideLabel}</ButtonText>
-            {pref === 'hide' && <ButtonIcon icon={Check} position="right" />}
-          </Button>
-
-          {canWarn && (
-            <Button
-              label={warnLabel}
-              size="large"
-              variant="solid"
-              color={pref === 'warn' ? 'primary' : 'secondary'}
-              onPress={() => {
-                onSelectPref('warn')
-                control.close()
-              }}>
-              <ButtonText style={[a.flex_1, a.text_left]}>
-                {warnLabel}
-              </ButtonText>
-              {pref === 'warn' && <ButtonIcon icon={Check} position="right" />}
-            </Button>
-          )}
-
-          <Button
-            label={ignoreLabel}
-            size="large"
-            variant="solid"
-            color={pref === 'ignore' ? 'primary' : 'secondary'}
-            onPress={() => {
-              onSelectPref('ignore')
-              control.close()
-            }}>
-            <ButtonText style={[a.flex_1, a.text_left]}>
-              {ignoreLabel}
-            </ButtonText>
-            {pref === 'ignore' && <ButtonIcon icon={Check} position="right" />}
-          </Button>
-        </Dialog.Inner>
-      </Dialog.Outer>
-    </>
-  )
-}
diff --git a/src/components/ModerationLabelPref/PreferenceButton.web.tsx b/src/components/ModerationLabelPref/PreferenceButton.web.tsx
deleted file mode 100644
index 8275686241..0000000000
--- a/src/components/ModerationLabelPref/PreferenceButton.web.tsx
+++ /dev/null
@@ -1,102 +0,0 @@
-import React from 'react'
-import {View} from 'react-native'
-import {useLingui} from '@lingui/react'
-import {msg} from '@lingui/macro'
-import {InterprettedLabelValueDefinition, LabelPreference} from '@atproto/api'
-
-import {useLabelBehaviorDescription} from '#/lib/moderation/useLabelBehaviorDescription'
-import {
-  NativeDropdown,
-  DropdownItem,
-} from '#/view/com/util/forms/NativeDropdown'
-
-import {useTheme, atoms as a} from '#/alf'
-import {Text} from '#/components/Typography'
-import {ArrowTriangleBottom_Stroke2_Corner1_Rounded as ArrowTriangleBottom} from '../icons/ArrowTriangle'
-import {useInteractionState} from '#/components/hooks/useInteractionState'
-
-const CHECK_ICON: DropdownItem['icon'] = {
-  web: ['fas', 'check'],
-  ios: {name: 'trash'}, //doesnt matter
-  android: '',
-}
-
-export function PreferenceButton({
-  pref,
-  labelValueDefinition,
-  onSelectPref,
-}: {
-  pref: LabelPreference
-  labelValueDefinition: InterprettedLabelValueDefinition
-  onSelectPref: (pref: LabelPreference) => void
-}) {
-  const {_} = useLingui()
-  const t = useTheme()
-
-  const {
-    state: hovered,
-    onIn: onHoverIn,
-    onOut: onHoverOut,
-  } = useInteractionState()
-
-  const settingDesc = useLabelBehaviorDescription(labelValueDefinition, pref)
-  const hideLabel = useLabelBehaviorDescription(labelValueDefinition, 'hide')
-  const warnLabel = useLabelBehaviorDescription(labelValueDefinition, 'warn')
-  const ignoreLabel = useLabelBehaviorDescription(
-    labelValueDefinition,
-    'ignore',
-  )
-  const canWarn = !(
-    labelValueDefinition.blurs === 'none' &&
-    labelValueDefinition.severity === 'none'
-  )
-
-  const dropdownItems: DropdownItem[] = []
-  dropdownItems.push({
-    icon: pref === 'hide' ? CHECK_ICON : undefined,
-    label: hideLabel,
-    onPress: () => onSelectPref('hide'),
-  })
-  if (canWarn) {
-    dropdownItems.push({
-      icon: pref === 'warn' ? CHECK_ICON : undefined,
-      label: warnLabel,
-      onPress: () => onSelectPref('warn'),
-    })
-  }
-  dropdownItems.push({
-    icon: pref === 'ignore' ? CHECK_ICON : undefined,
-    label: ignoreLabel,
-    onPress: () => onSelectPref('ignore'),
-  })
-
-  return (
-    <NativeDropdown
-      items={dropdownItems}
-      accessibilityLabel={_(msg`More post options`)}
-      accessibilityHint="">
-      <View
-        style={[
-          a.flex_row,
-          a.align_center,
-          a.justify_end,
-          a.gap_xs,
-          a.py_xs,
-          a.rounded_2xs,
-          hovered && {
-            // @ts-ignore
-            textDecorationLine: 'underline',
-            textDecorationColor: t.palette.primary_500,
-          },
-        ]}
-        // @ts-ignore
-        onMouseEnter={onHoverIn}
-        onMouseLeave={onHoverOut}>
-        <Text style={[{color: t.palette.primary_500}, a.font_semibold]}>
-          {settingDesc}
-        </Text>
-        <ArrowTriangleBottom width={8} fill={t.palette.primary_500} />
-      </View>
-    </NativeDropdown>
-  )
-}
diff --git a/src/components/ModerationLabelPref/index.tsx b/src/components/ModerationLabelPref/index.tsx
index f80e6d8387..e8c1c66d5c 100644
--- a/src/components/ModerationLabelPref/index.tsx
+++ b/src/components/ModerationLabelPref/index.tsx
@@ -1,8 +1,14 @@
 import React from 'react'
-import {View} from 'react-native'
+import {Pressable, View} from 'react-native'
 import {InterprettedLabelValueDefinition, LabelPreference} from '@atproto/api'
+import {useLingui} from '@lingui/react'
+import {msg, Trans} from '@lingui/macro'
 
 import {useLabelStrings} from '#/lib/moderation/useLabelStrings'
+import {
+  useLabelBehaviorDescription,
+  useLabelLongBehaviorDescription,
+} from '#/lib/moderation/useLabelBehaviorDescription'
 import {
   usePreferencesQuery,
   usePreferencesSetContentLabelMutation,
@@ -10,7 +16,10 @@ import {
 
 import {useTheme, atoms as a} from '#/alf'
 import {Text} from '#/components/Typography'
-import {PreferenceButton} from './PreferenceButton'
+import * as Dialog from '#/components/Dialog'
+import {Button, ButtonText, ButtonIcon} from '#/components/Button'
+import {ArrowTriangleBottom_Stroke2_Corner1_Rounded as ArrowTriangleBottom} from '../icons/ArrowTriangle'
+import {Check_Stroke2_Corner0_Rounded as Check} from '../icons/Check'
 
 export function ModerationLabelPref({
   labelValueDefinition,
@@ -21,12 +30,35 @@ export function ModerationLabelPref({
   labelerDid: string | undefined
   disabled?: boolean
 }) {
+  const {_} = useLingui()
   const t = useTheme()
-  const allLabelStrings = useLabelStrings()
-  const {data: preferences} = usePreferencesQuery()
-  const {mutate, variables} = usePreferencesSetContentLabelMutation()
+  const control = Dialog.useDialogControl()
 
   const {identifier} = labelValueDefinition
+  const {data: preferences} = usePreferencesQuery()
+  const {mutate, variables} = usePreferencesSetContentLabelMutation()
+  const savedPref = labelerDid
+    ? preferences?.moderationPrefs.mods.find(m => m.did === labelerDid)?.labels[
+        identifier
+      ]
+    : preferences?.moderationPrefs.labels[identifier]
+  const pref = variables?.visibility ?? savedPref ?? 'warn'
+
+  const settingDesc = useLabelBehaviorDescription(labelValueDefinition, pref)
+  const hideLabel = useLabelLongBehaviorDescription(
+    labelValueDefinition,
+    'hide',
+  )
+  const warnLabel = useLabelLongBehaviorDescription(
+    labelValueDefinition,
+    'warn',
+  )
+  const ignoreLabel = useLabelLongBehaviorDescription(
+    labelValueDefinition,
+    'ignore',
+  )
+
+  const allLabelStrings = useLabelStrings()
   const labelStrings = labelValueDefinition.locales[0] // TODO look up locale
     ? labelValueDefinition.locales[0]
     : labelValueDefinition.identifier in allLabelStrings
@@ -36,34 +68,141 @@ export function ModerationLabelPref({
         description: `Labeled "${labelValueDefinition.identifier}"`,
       }
 
-  const savedPref = labelerDid
-    ? preferences?.moderationPrefs.mods.find(m => m.did === labelerDid)?.labels[
-        identifier
-      ]
-    : preferences?.moderationPrefs.labels[identifier]
-  const pref = variables?.visibility ?? savedPref ?? 'warn'
+  const canWarn = !(
+    labelValueDefinition.blurs === 'none' &&
+    labelValueDefinition.severity === 'none'
+  )
 
   const onSelectPref = (newPref: LabelPreference) =>
     mutate({label: identifier, visibility: newPref, labelerDid})
 
   return (
-    <View style={[a.flex_row, a.justify_between, a.gap_lg, a.align_center]}>
-      <View style={[a.gap_xs, a.flex_1]}>
+    <>
+      <Pressable
+        onPress={() => control.open()}
+        accessibilityLabel={settingDesc}
+        accessibilityHint=""
+        style={[
+          a.flex_row,
+          a.justify_between,
+          a.gap_sm,
+          a.align_center,
+          t.atoms.bg_contrast_50,
+          a.px_lg,
+          a.py_lg,
+          a.rounded_sm,
+        ]}>
         <Text style={[a.font_bold]}>{labelStrings.name}</Text>
-        <Text style={[t.atoms.text_contrast_medium, a.leading_snug]}>
+
+        <Text
+          style={[t.atoms.text_contrast_medium, a.flex_1]}
+          numberOfLines={1}>
           {labelStrings.description}
         </Text>
-      </View>
-      <View style={[{width: 110}]}>
         {!disabled && (
-          <PreferenceButton
-            name={labelStrings.name}
-            pref={pref}
-            labelValueDefinition={labelValueDefinition}
-            onSelectPref={onSelectPref}
-          />
+          <View
+            style={[
+              {width: 100},
+              a.flex_row,
+              a.align_center,
+              a.justify_end,
+              a.gap_xs,
+              a.rounded_2xs,
+            ]}>
+            {!disabled && (
+              <Text style={[t.atoms.text_contrast_medium, a.font_semibold]}>
+                {settingDesc}
+              </Text>
+            )}
+            <ArrowTriangleBottom
+              width={8}
+              fill={t.atoms.text_contrast_medium.color}
+            />
+          </View>
         )}
-      </View>
-    </View>
+      </Pressable>
+
+      <Dialog.Outer control={control}>
+        <Dialog.Handle />
+
+        <Dialog.Inner
+          label={_(msg`Settings: ${labelValueDefinition.identifier}`)}
+          style={[a.gap_sm]}>
+          <Text style={[a.text_2xl, a.font_bold, a.pb_xs, t.atoms.text]}>
+            {labelStrings.name}
+          </Text>
+          <Text style={[a.text_md, a.pb_sm, t.atoms.text_contrast_medium]}>
+            {labelStrings.description}
+          </Text>
+          {disabled ? (
+            <Button
+              label={_(msg`Close`)}
+              size="large"
+              variant="solid"
+              color="secondary"
+              onPress={() => control.close()}>
+              <ButtonText style={[a.flex_1, a.text_left]}>
+                <Trans>Close</Trans>
+              </ButtonText>
+            </Button>
+          ) : (
+            <>
+              <Button
+                label={hideLabel}
+                size="large"
+                variant="solid"
+                color={pref === 'hide' ? 'primary' : 'secondary'}
+                onPress={() => {
+                  onSelectPref('hide')
+                  control.close()
+                }}>
+                <ButtonText style={[a.flex_1, a.text_left]}>
+                  {hideLabel}
+                </ButtonText>
+                {pref === 'hide' && (
+                  <ButtonIcon icon={Check} position="right" />
+                )}
+              </Button>
+
+              {canWarn && (
+                <Button
+                  label={warnLabel}
+                  size="large"
+                  variant="solid"
+                  color={pref === 'warn' ? 'primary' : 'secondary'}
+                  onPress={() => {
+                    onSelectPref('warn')
+                    control.close()
+                  }}>
+                  <ButtonText style={[a.flex_1, a.text_left]}>
+                    {warnLabel}
+                  </ButtonText>
+                  {pref === 'warn' && (
+                    <ButtonIcon icon={Check} position="right" />
+                  )}
+                </Button>
+              )}
+
+              <Button
+                label={ignoreLabel}
+                size="large"
+                variant="solid"
+                color={!disabled && pref === 'ignore' ? 'primary' : 'secondary'}
+                onPress={() => {
+                  onSelectPref('ignore')
+                  control.close()
+                }}>
+                <ButtonText style={[a.flex_1, a.text_left]}>
+                  {ignoreLabel}
+                </ButtonText>
+                {pref === 'ignore' && (
+                  <ButtonIcon icon={Check} position="right" />
+                )}
+              </Button>
+            </>
+          )}
+        </Dialog.Inner>
+      </Dialog.Outer>
+    </>
   )
 }
diff --git a/src/screens/Profile/Sections/Labels.tsx b/src/screens/Profile/Sections/Labels.tsx
index 63a75900ee..6e203f57ef 100644
--- a/src/screens/Profile/Sections/Labels.tsx
+++ b/src/screens/Profile/Sections/Labels.tsx
@@ -141,8 +141,6 @@ export function ProfileLabelsSectionInner({
       ) as InterprettedLabelValueDefinition[]
   }, [labelerInfo, labelValues])
 
-  console.log(headerHeight, scrollElRef.current)
-
   return (
     <ScrollView
       ref={scrollElRef}
@@ -195,20 +193,15 @@ export function ProfileLabelsSectionInner({
           ) : null}
         </View>
         {labelDefs.length > 0 && (
-          <View
-            style={[a.mt_xl, t.atoms.bg_contrast_25, a.rounded_md, a.py_xs]}>
-            {labelDefs.map((labelDef, i) => {
+          <View style={[a.mt_xl, a.gap_sm]}>
+            {labelDefs.map(labelDef => {
               return (
-                <React.Fragment key={labelDef.identifier}>
-                  {i !== 0 && <Divider />}
-                  <View style={[a.py_md, a.px_md]}>
-                    <ModerationLabelPref
-                      disabled={isSubscribed ? undefined : true}
-                      labelValueDefinition={labelDef}
-                      labelerDid={labelerInfo.creator.did}
-                    />
-                  </View>
-                </React.Fragment>
+                <ModerationLabelPref
+                  key={labelDef.identifier}
+                  disabled={isSubscribed ? undefined : true}
+                  labelValueDefinition={labelDef}
+                  labelerDid={labelerInfo.creator.did}
+                />
               )
             })}
           </View>