diff --git a/src/view/screens/ProfileList.tsx b/src/view/screens/ProfileList.tsx
index a0002b445b..acd603126b 100644
--- a/src/view/screens/ProfileList.tsx
+++ b/src/view/screens/ProfileList.tsx
@@ -393,76 +393,72 @@ function Header({
     try {
       await listMuteMutation.mutateAsync({uri: list.uri, mute: true})
       Toast.show(_(msg({message: 'List muted', context: 'toast'})))
+      logger.metric(
+        'moderation:subscribedToList',
+        {listType: 'mute'},
+        {statsig: true},
+      )
     } catch {
       Toast.show(
         _(
           msg`There was an issue. Please check your internet connection and try again.`,
         ),
       )
-      return
     }
-    logger.metric(
-      'moderation:subscribedToList',
-      {listType: 'mute'},
-      {statsig: true},
-    )
   }, [list, listMuteMutation, _])
 
   const onUnsubscribeMute = useCallback(async () => {
     try {
       await listMuteMutation.mutateAsync({uri: list.uri, mute: false})
       Toast.show(_(msg({message: 'List unmuted', context: 'toast'})))
+      logger.metric(
+        'moderation:unsubscribedFromList',
+        {listType: 'mute'},
+        {statsig: true},
+      )
     } catch {
       Toast.show(
         _(
           msg`There was an issue. Please check your internet connection and try again.`,
         ),
       )
-      return
     }
-    logger.metric(
-      'moderation:unsubscribedFromList',
-      {listType: 'mute'},
-      {statsig: true},
-    )
   }, [list, listMuteMutation, _])
 
   const onSubscribeBlock = useCallback(async () => {
     try {
       await listBlockMutation.mutateAsync({uri: list.uri, block: true})
       Toast.show(_(msg({message: 'List blocked', context: 'toast'})))
+      logger.metric(
+        'moderation:subscribedToList',
+        {listType: 'block'},
+        {statsig: true},
+      )
     } catch {
       Toast.show(
         _(
           msg`There was an issue. Please check your internet connection and try again.`,
         ),
       )
-      return
     }
-    logger.metric(
-      'moderation:subscribedToList',
-      {listType: 'block'},
-      {statsig: true},
-    )
   }, [list, listBlockMutation, _])
 
   const onUnsubscribeBlock = useCallback(async () => {
     try {
       await listBlockMutation.mutateAsync({uri: list.uri, block: false})
       Toast.show(_(msg({message: 'List unblocked', context: 'toast'})))
+      logger.metric(
+        'moderation:unsubscribedFromList',
+        {listType: 'block'},
+        {statsig: true},
+      )
     } catch {
       Toast.show(
         _(
           msg`There was an issue. Please check your internet connection and try again.`,
         ),
       )
-      return
     }
-    logger.metric(
-      'moderation:unsubscribedFromList',
-      {listType: 'block'},
-      {statsig: true},
-    )
   }, [list, listBlockMutation, _])
 
   const onPressEdit = useCallback(() => {